E-commerce business challenges: going for sole trader or limited company

Here we’ll go over the basics of what sole trader and limited company structures mean for ecommerce businesses, the advantages and disadvantages of both, and how to make the switch.

September 19, 2024
-

0

min read

For most e-commerce entrepreneurs, the journey begins as a sole trader—a straightforward, low-cost option that allows you to get your business off the ground with minimal delay and expense. If it’s your first time running your own business, the simplicity of operating as a sole trader can feel reassuringly simple. But as your business grows and your ambitions expand, you realise why limited companies are the default for so many businesses. 

When it comes to making the transition from sole trader to limited company, there’s no hard and fast rule about when to do it. But in general, you will find that you have more options as a limited company about how to run your business, from tax strategy to credit.

Understanding sole trader vs limited company structures for ecommerce

Sole trader structure for ecommerce 

Sole traders are the most common way of operating a business, accounting for 56% of the UK private sector's business population, or 3.1 million businesses

Operating as a sole trader means that you and your business are legally the same entity. You’re responsible for all aspects of the business, from decision-making to financial obligations. 

This simplicity makes it an appealing option for those just starting out or looking to dip their toe in business. Advantages include:

  • It’s easy to get started: Becoming a sole trader is quick and easy, with minimal paperwork required. You simply need to register with HMRC and can start trading almost immediately.
  • You’re in control: As a sole trader, you have complete control over your business decisions. There’s no need to consult with shareholders or directors, making the decision-making process faster and more straightforward.
  • Simple tax reporting: Your business income is reported on your personal tax return, and you can use cash basis accounting if your turnover is under £150,000, which makes bookkeeping more straightforward..

However, while simplicity is all good for businesses starting out, you may find that you run into walls as a sole trader if you try and expand. Disadvantages to consider include:

  • Unlimited liability: The advantage of being a sole trader is that you are your business. But this can also be the most significant drawback, as you are also bound by what’s known as ‘unlimited liability’, rather than limited liability as a limited company. This means that if your business incurs debt, you’re personally liable, which puts your personal assets at risk.
  • Limited access to finance: Sole traders may find it more challenging to secure financing. Banks and investors often view sole traders as higher risk because there’s no legal separation between personal and business assets.
  • Perception of scale: Some suppliers and customers may perceive sole traders as less credible or stable compared to limited companies, which can affect your business relationships and opportunities..

Limited company structure for ecommerce 

A limited company, on the other hand, is a separate legal entity from its owners. This structure offers distinct advantages, particularly for e-commerce businesses looking to scale.

These include:

  • Limited liability: One of the major benefits is that your personal assets are protected. Your liability is limited to the value of your shares in the company, safeguarding you from business debts.
  • Tax efficiency: Limited companies often enjoy more tax-efficient structures. For instance, corporation tax rates can be lower than personal income tax rates, and you have the flexibility to pay yourself through a combination of salary and dividends, potentially reducing your overall tax burden.
  • Better access to credit: Limited companies generally have better access to financing options, including bank loans and investment capital. The corporate structure instils more confidence in lenders and investors, facilitating growth and expansion.
  • Professional image: Operating as a limited company can enhance your business’s professional image and credibility. A registered company name conveys stability and reliability, which can be crucial when negotiating with suppliers, customers, and partners.

That said, these advantages do come at a cost, though it may be one that is worth it all things considered. Make sure you bear in mind:

  • Increased administrative burden: Running a limited company involves more extensive regulatory and reporting requirements. You’ll need to file annual accounts, maintain statutory records, and comply with company law obligations, which can be time-consuming and costly. Most limited companies will employ an accountant to handle these affairs.
  • Reduced control: Although this is less of an issue if you’re the sole director and shareholder, technically, decisions within a limited company are subject to formal governance processes. This can slow down decision-making, particularly as your company grows and involves more stakeholders.

How to choose the right structure as an ecommerce business 

When choosing your business structure, you need to consider your goals and long term plans and ensure you’re positioning yourself for success. The move from sole trader to limited company can come at any time – indeed some businesses start as limited companies straight away to minimise any issues in transition. 

Consider the following issues when you’re choosing the structure for your business:

Growth potential and relationships

For e-commerce businesses, access to the right products and markets is everything and credibility is often a key factor in building trust with customers and suppliers. 

  • A limited company structure can provide that additional layer of professionalism, which may be crucial if you’re looking to scale, enter new contracts, or secure partnerships with larger distributors.
  • As your e-commerce business grows, the limited liability and tax advantages of a limited company can become more attractive. 
  • If your business is generating substantial profits, the ability to optimise your tax position through a limited company structure could result in significant savings.

Growth with financing

As a limited company, you’re likely to have better access to financing. This can be particularly important for e-commerce businesses that need to invest in inventory finance, marketing, or new technology to stay competitive. 

  • Limited companies have access to more detailed accounts which can help lenders assess risk more accurately.
  • There are a wider range of lenders for limited companies, giving you the opportunity to choose the best deal for you and your needs.
  • Your debts as a limited company accrue to the business, although some lenders may also ask for a personal guarantee, particularly for unsecured loans.

Risk management

If your e-commerce business involves significant financial risk—such as high upfront inventory costs, long payment cycles, or exposure to fluctuating market conditions—operating as a limited company can provide vital protection. 

  • By separating your personal assets from your business liabilities, you reduce the risk to your personal finances, allowing you to take calculated business risks with greater confidence.
  • As a limited company, you can use business structure to silo off areas of your business. For example, if taking on a big contract or moving into a new region, you can do so as a distinct business entity, insulating the rest of your business.

Managing administration

The trade-off for the benefits of a limited company is increased administrative obligations. 

  • Filing annual accounts, managing payroll, and staying compliant with company law require more time and resources than the relatively straightforward obligations of a sole trader. 
  • These will usually require hiring a professional to manage them, depending on the degree of complexity.

However, these tasks are manageable with the right support, such as hiring an accountant or using accounting software designed for small businesses.

How to move your ecommerce business from sole trader to limited company

If you decide that transitioning to a limited company is the right move for your e-commerce business, here are the steps you’ll need to follow:

  1.  Choose a company name and register with companies House: Select a unique company name that complies with Companies House regulations. Once you’ve decided on a name, you’ll need to register your company with Companies House, which involves completing a straightforward online form. You’ll receive a Certificate of Incorporation, confirming that your company legally exists.
  2. Set up a business bank account: A limited company must have a separate business bank account. This is crucial for keeping your business finances distinct from your personal finances, ensuring clear accounting. simplifying tax reporting and building business credit.
  3. Register for corporation tax: Within three months of starting your limited company, you must register for corporation tax with HMRC. You’ll need to pay corporation tax on your company’s profits, which may be lower than the income tax you’d pay as a sole trader.
  4.  Transfer business assets: If you’re transitioning from a sole trader, you may need to transfer assets such as inventory, equipment, or intellectual property to the new limited company. This process can have tax implications, so it’s advisable to seek professional advice to ensure you manage this transition effectively.
  5. Notify stakeholders and update contracts: Inform your suppliers, customers, and any other stakeholders about the change in your business structure. You may also need to update contracts to reflect the new company entity. This ensures that all business dealings are conducted under the limited company’s name, protecting your legal position.

Can you switch back?

While transitioning to a limited company offers many benefits, some business owners may wonder if they can revert to a sole trader status if circumstances change. 

While this is possible, it can be more complex due to potential tax implications, particularly if assets need to be transferred back. It’s important to carefully consider your long-term business goals before making the switch and to consult with an accountant to understand the full implications.

Choosing the right structure for your ecommerce business 

Deciding whether to operate as a sole trader or a limited company is a major decision in the lifecycle of any business. 

While the simplicity and flexibility of a sole trader structure may appeal to those just starting out, the benefits of a limited company—such as limited liability, tax efficiency, and greater access to finance—make it an essential option for businesses looking to grow.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your business’s specific circumstances, goals, and risk tolerance. Transitioning to a limited company can provide the foundation for scaling your business, protecting your personal assets, and enhancing your credibility in the marketplace. 

And if you find yourself in need of a small business loan, iwoca is here to help. An iwoca Flexi-Loan can help you access credit quickly, with transparent fees, tailored decisions and simple repayments.

  • Apply in minutes
  • Get approved within 24 hours
  • There are no long-term commitments and we don’t charge for early repayments

{{calculator-cta="/components"}}

Ryanpal Ubha

Ryanpal Ubha is a Credit Risk Manager at iwoca. His experience includes managing equity portfolios during his time at Nottingham, as well as internships at CNN and ONIX Life Sciences.

About iwoca

  • Borrow up to £500,000
  • Repay early with no fees
  • From 1 day to 24 months
  • Applying won't affect your credit score

iwoca is one of Europe's leading digital lenders. Since  2012, we've helped over 90,000 business owners access fast, flexible finance.
Whether you want to manage cash flow, invest in growth, or seize new opportunities, iwoca can help you achieve your goals with simple, fair and transparent business loans designed around your needs.

Learn more

Borrow £1,000 - £1,000,000 to buy new stock, invest in growth plans or just keep your cash flow smooth.

  • Applying won’t impact your credit score
  • Get an answer in 24 hours
  • Trusted by 60,000 UK businesses since 2012
  • A benefit point goes here
two women looking at a tablet